Yesterday the HMO Kaiser Permanente released an online video game targeting childhood obesity.
It's meant to teach kids more about healthy eating and according to the press release it's aimed at kids between the ages of 9-10.
Here are the main components of the games.
Eats too much - you zap away at portions, with no explanation or instruction as to how to do so without inviting hunger
Not very strong - you add protein sources to an enourmous portion of pasta and 3 large slices of bread.
Too much junk food - you help a kid choose a carrot, a banana juice and water instead of granola bars, fruit roll ups and chocolate bars (yup, that'll happen).
Doesn't exercise enough - you help a kid stop watching TV and go out and play soccer (by himself)
Needs to play more - you help a girl jump rope instead of play with a yoyo (by herself)
Teeth and bones are weak - help a kid to sit down to a glass of juice, a glass of milk, a giant bowl of cereal, a giant hunk of cheese and a yogurt.
Tired all the time - Click a machine that "speeds up" a boy named Matthew's speed doing jumping jacks (in a gym, by himself)
Skips breakfast - Click a stopwatch so the kid stops and eats breakfast (a bowl of cereal or even "just a banana".
This is just more part and parcel of the same old useless messages bundled with little explanation, conflicting portion sizes and non-inspiring depictions (yay, jumping jacks in a gym by myself are fun!).
Do people really think kids don't know that exercise is healthier for them than watching TV? That vegetables are healthier choices than chocolate bars? That breakfast is a healthy start to the day? That doing more exercise is healthier than doing less? That smaller portions lead to smaller waists?
Of course kids know all of these things.
What they need to be taught is not things that they know, but things that they don't know.
Not to beat a dead horse but they need to be taught about caloric intake vs. caloric expenditure, they need to be taught hunger prevention strategies, they need to be taught how to be thoughtful with food rather than blindly and unrealistically restrictive.
If this is cutting edge, the edge is duller than I thought.
You can play the game yourself here and come to your own conclusions.
I give it an F. It doesn't teach kids anything they don't already know and instead gives them a parentally acceptable reason not to turn off the computer.
Thursday, September 27, 2007
The Incredible Adventures of the Amazing Food Detective - Review
Wednesday, September 26, 2007
Do you have scale addiction?

It's certainly not a condition written about in medical textbooks.
I'm talking about scale addiction. An affliction that causes the sufferer, usually someone in the midst of a weight loss effort, to step on the scale multiple times a day whereupon if the scale does not go down or goes up, they suffer mild to severe mental anguish.
I've met many folks who are scale addicts.
They tell me that rationally they understand that getting on the scale multiple times a day won't make a difference, but that they just can't help themselves.
For those folks I usually offer to babysit their scales in my office or I recommend that they turn them over, take out the batteries or put tape on the solar strip.
The thing is scales are truly frustrating devices because they don't simply measure caloric intake vs. caloric expenditure. They measure clothing, water retention, constipation and time of day differences.
Folks who do weigh frequently will know that weight fluctuates both day by day and within a day.
So for scale addicts out there, here are two things you need to know.
Firstly, there's 3,500 calories in a pound, and while bodies are not mathematical instruments whereby if you do or don't eat 3,500 calories you'll see a pound change on the scale, bodies do obey the laws of thermodynamics and if you step on a scale on a Wednesday and it's 3 pounds heavier than Tuesday, unless you consumed at least 10,500 calories more than you burned, the scale is weighing something other than true weight.
Secondly, your weight doesn't matter. What do I mean by that? To put it simply, what moves the number on the scale is not the act of standing on the scale, it's what you're doing and choosing during the times you're not standing on the scale. It's your lifestyle and your choices that change your weight. You need to determine how you're doing by how you're doing. What have your dietary choices been like? How's your fitness? Are you being thoughtful? Are you organized and consistent?
Scales can be helpful to illustrate trends, but weight fluctuation, both inter and intra day fluctuations are normal.
At the end of the day, it's your life that can change the scale, not the other way around.
My recommendations? During a weight loss effort weigh yourself once a week, stark naked Wednesday morning before breakfast. During a weight maintenance effort weigh yourself daily and get to learn your body's weight fluctuations and more importantly, use the scale to nip any weight regain in the bud.
Break the habit, stop the weighing.
(P.S. Those aren't my feet, just a scary picture from the internet)
Tuesday, September 25, 2007
Alberta's Useless Child Gestures
Last week the Province of Alberta unveiled their new warrior designed to help combat the rising tide of childhood obesity. It's called Create a Movement and for a cost of $2,000,000 your Province can design one too.
In a nutshell it's a series of slick media advertisements and then a slick webpage all of which serve to shuffle Albertans off to pick up their copies of Canada's Food Guide.
The crux of their advertising campaign is fear. The goal of the campaign is to scare Albertan parents and kids into action. Their target,
"Unhealthy weights among our generation is on the fast track to replace smoking as Canada’s #1 killer"And when I say scare tactics, I mean scare tactics. Here's one of their scary commercials:
So let's say you've just watched the scary commercial and you've decided to look past the fact that the child that the doctor is speaking to clearly has a very healthy body weight and is not at risk for any weight related chronic diseases and in fact makes the entire commercial seem rather ridiculous and fear mongering and you click yourself over to the createamovement.ca webpage. What help will you find there?
Pretty much none.
The entire website reminds kids to, "Eat Smart", "Move More", and of course, "Start a Movement".
There are T-shirt stencils for you to download, certain to make you the coolest kids in your class.
There is wallpaper for your desktop, certain to make you turn your computer off to go and "Eat Smart" and "Move More".
There are copies of all of the scary commercials and there are "Webisodes".
Here's an example of a "Webisode" - a teenage skateboarder with a BMI in the neighbourhood of 20 talks of how he drinks two Cokes a day. The hostess then tells him that the Coke he's drinking leads him to gain 12lbs in a year. She then goes on to talk about the sugar in pop.
Interesting that the "Webisode" that clearly is anti-sugar doesn't mention that juice has as much or more sugar as pop and that chocolate milk has more. Also, do you really think that first skater should be aiming for a 12lb weight loss by stopping his Cola habit, and lastly was picking healthy active teens to focus on - doesn't that miss this website's target audience (the sedentary overweight ones)?
The "Facts" section of the website has the same old stuff - eat less fat, eat more vegetables, get off the couch, and the resource section - of course it points you to Canada's Food Guide (Canada's Food Guide to Unhealthy Eating), My Food Guide (The bad joke that is My Food Guide) and Eattracker (Eattracker - your new weight gain weapon) (click the links for my reviews therein) where juice, chocolate milk, refined flour and red meat are all "healthy" choices.
Clearly there's some care regarding energy because at the bottom right hand corner of every page is a little graphic that illustrates how long you have to run to burn off some common junk food items. But of course the website has completely ignored calories and while they point out it takes 43 minutes to run off a fountain cola, they fail to note that it would take just as long to run off juice and longer to run off chocolate milk.
All in all I can't blame the folks putting together the website - they're just promoting the messages our government has deemed to be helpful.
Quick question - if the eat healthier, move more diet worked, do you really think that close to 70% of Canadians would be overweight or obese?
Another question - Do you think this website is telling kids anything at all that they don't already know?
It's time that governments and health professionals get past the tried and true messages that not only aren't helpful, are frankly unhelpful. Healthy eating does not mean healthy weights. Exercise is not in and of itself sufficient for dramatic weight loss. Calories count.
Kids and adults need to be taught that healthy eating and weight management are two separate healthy endeavors, with healthy eating involving food choices and weight management calorie choices. They need to be taught means to prevent hunger. They need to be taught the sad truths of the Calories burned through exercise.
Basically, they need a new message, because this tired old one, the one we've had for the past 50 years, the eat smarter, move more message, doesn't work.
The site did succeed with me however - its reminder of just how woefully inadequate (nonexistent) our government's guidance on weight management is certainly left me wanting to "create a movement".
[Hat tip: Julie from It Must Have Been Something I Ate]
Monday, September 24, 2007
I Need your Help

Today I'm taking a day off nutrition blogging to ask you for your help.
Next Sunday I'm running in the CIBC Run for the Cure, a charity run supporting breast cancer research.
It's a rare individual who escapes being touched by breast cancer as 1 in 9 women will develop breast cancer in their lifetimes. Obesity is definitely a risk factor and weight loss appears to be protective against recurrence.
My office, the Bariatric Medical Institute, over the course of the past 3 years has raised over $70,000 for Run for the Cure. That picture up above is part of our team last year when for the second time in as many years, we raised more money than any other office based team in Ottawa. This year for some reason, fund raising has been more challenging and with the run next weekend, we're sitting just shy of $20,000.
I put a great deal of time and energy into this blog and while I promise that I will never ask my readers to pay for access, I am hopeful that if you enjoy my work, you will consider donating to my Run for the Cure effort.
To donate click the pink button below which will take you to the CIBC website. You can choose to give anonymously, you can use a credit card and if you donate more than $10, you'll receive a tax receipt.
Thank you and back to normal programming tomorrow.
Sincerely,
Yoni
Friday, September 21, 2007
More Doctors Smoke Camels
Some things never change, but clearly some things do.
Today for Funny Fridays (new subscribers - Friday's my day off anger) is an old commercial for Camel cigarettes.
Have a great weekend!
Thursday, September 20, 2007
Sugar is Sugar
In a bit of a flying pig type moment, the Center for Science in the Public Interest has apparently joined hands with Big Food (in the form of the Corn Refiners Association) in chastising the President's Cancer Panel's report that vilifies high fructose corn syrup (HFCS).
HFCS is a sweetener that's made from corn and used widely in sugared soda. It has been demonized by consumers due to the suggestion that it somehow, independently of the laws of thermodynamics, causes those ingesting it to gain more weight than those consuming more "natural" sugars.
In fact, this attitude has become so prevalent that there are now foods that splash the words, "HFCS Free" on their front labels.
CSPI, like me, thinks sugar is sugar, whether it's god sugar or HFCS and in their letter state,
"the 2006-2007 Annual Report of the President's Cancer Panel diverges from accepted science in its unfair effort to identify high fructose corn syrup as a uniquely important contributor to obesity, which is a risk factor for cancer."Bottom line here - CSPI thinks we all eat too much sugar and it doesn't really matter where the sugar comes from, sugar is sugar and there's no sense in perpetuating a myth that one sugar is better than any other (even if God made it).
"The report's multiple, pejorative references to HFCS are unwarranted and risk mistakenly reinforcing the myth - now effectively disproved by a steadily growing body of research evidence - that HFCS and sugar might affect the body differently"
Wednesday, September 19, 2007
"You should stop losing weight"
In my practice I get to see a great many people lose a great deal of weight and I've noticed two trends.
Firstly it's usually somewhere between a 15 and 20 pound weight loss when folks start noticing, but it's the second trend I want to talk about, the, "You should stop losing weight" trend whereby if you lose enough weight, folks will start telling you to stop.
In my experience it happens at somewhere around the 15-20% mark (i.e. a 30-40lb weight loss if your starting weight is 200lbs). Now there is a difference in terms of how starting weight affects this phenomenon and the higher the starting weight, the less likely this phenomenon will occur but as an anecdotal rule, if your starting weight is less than 250lbs and you lose more than 20% of your starting weight, somebody will tell you to stop. They'll often even do so despite the fact that you may still want to lose more weight and may still have a significant amount of medical risk associated with your weight.
Sometimes they'll even come right out and say you look bad.
I've got two theories about this. There's the less likely theory - jealousy, but honestly I don't believe that plays a big role for most folks. I think the more likely theory is the fact that consciously or perhaps unconsciously as a function of evolutionary biology, we interpret weight loss as reflective of illness.
The fact is that many major and sometime fatal illnesses have a wasting away component to them and I wonder if we as a species have it hardwired in us to recognize weight loss as a sign of illness. Many of us too have personally watched friends and relatives waste away and seeing a friend or a relative lose weight may trigger memories and emotions that less than pleasant.
For all those obesity researchers who may be reading my blog, I think this phenomenon would be a fascinating study and it's certainly not one I've read about. There'd be two ways to study it. One with a prospective study whereby the folks losing weight keep track of when they first run into someone whose concerned about their weight loss or perhaps an easier study using photographs of folks as they lose weight with captive audiences and well designed questions.
Anybody out there experience this phenomenon?
Tuesday, September 18, 2007
Canada's Cheese Plan Stinks
Rosie Schwartz, nutritional columnist for the National Post, author and RD has exposed yet another instance where our government is bending over for Canada's dairy industry.
To explain let me take you back to the 80s, when the first low-fat cheeses began to hit the market.
They tasted terrible didn't they?
Nowadays though they don't taste half bad. In fact in some cases, it's almost impossible to distinguish the low-fat version from the regular.
The reason low-fat cheeses taste better nowadays is that over the years the cheese making industry has found ways to improve taste while still keeping the saturated fat levels low. They've been adding milk solids and whey and other foods that affect the "mouthfeel" of cheese.
By lowering fat content, calories are lowered and saturated fat levels are lowered.
Those are good things, right? Lowering calories and saturated fat in our diets is supposed to be healthy, right? Health Canada and our government in general would want that, right?
You'd sure think so. You'd think that the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA), an agency who Rosie points out's mandate is to,
"protect Canadians from preventable health risks"would want and encourage Canadians to consume less saturated fat and calories and in so doing help protect Canadians from chronic conditions like heart disease and the number one preventable cause of death in Canada, obesity.
You'd sure think so.
But of course you'd be dead wrong.
The CFIA actually wants to limit the amount of whey that cheese makers use to make their cheese, thereby requiring cheese makers to utilize more fluid milk, increasing the saturated fat content of cheese, the calories of cheese, the price of cheese and decreasing the palatability of low-fat cheeses.
So why would they want to do that?
Perhaps because the CFIA doesn't work for Health Canada, the CFIA works directly for the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Agriculture works directly for our farmers. You see, by limiting the whey that cheese makers are "allowed" to use they will require cheese makers to buy more liquid milk from Canada's dairy farmers.
So what does Health Canada have to say on the matter? Health Canada who as I mentioned yesterday quite literally launched the Food Guide while basically holding hands with the Secretary of State for Agriculture?
Rosie managed to contact Renee Bergeron a Happy Corporations spokesperson who had this to say,
"Based on our initial review, Health Canada considers that the proposed changes to cheese standards would not be expected to compromise the nutritional quality of cheeses and cheese products."I wonder which corporate shill in Health Canada had the honour of signing their name to a paper that stated that raising the saturated fat content and calories in cheeses wouldn't compromise their nutritional quality.
Health Canada and CFIA, please stop cutting the cheese.
Monday, September 17, 2007
I'm moving to Australia
You know that was actually the plan once. Before I finished my residency I had met with some recruiters from Australia and was offered a job doing medicine in rural Australia - then I met my wife.
Today I'm once again itching to move, but today it's simply because Australia is the first country I've come across (there may be more) that has not bowed to Big Food's pressure and has actually gone and done what in Canada and the United States is almost unthinkable.
What have they done?
They've officially recognized fruit juice to be the glass of God sugar that it is.
They've even informed parents that half a glass a day is a maximum!
Contrast that with our god-awful Food Guide that states drinking juice is as good for you as eating fruit.
Here's what Australia's national science agency the CSIRO, the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, has to say about juice:
"Fruit juices provide nutrients but almost no fibre so they don’t give the same benefits as eating fresh fruit. Fruit is also more filling than fruit juice. Juices are high in kilojoules and the sugar in fruit juice may play a part in tooth decay. It is recommended that children do not drink more than ½ cup of fruit juice each day."They've also got some sensible words regarding milk as they are aware that you can actually eat dairy products rather than drink them and have an entire campaign entitled, Give Thirsty Kids Water
Just in case you've forgotten, Happy Corporations....I mean Health Canada includes juice as a serving of fruit (complete with pictorial reference in the Guide) and does not give any maximums on its consumption.
"Make water your beverage of choice. Milk, fortified soy beverages and 100% juice are also healthy options. Make them part of your recommended number of Food Guide Servings per day."Regarding milk, Health Canada believes it to be a magic food - apparently the only substance on the planet that can provide vitamin D.
"Encourage young children to drink water to quench their thirst and replenish body fluids. Canada 's Food Guide recommends that children and adults choose vegetables and fruit more often than juice. Children also need a total of 500 mL (2 cups) of milk every day to help meet their requirement for vitamin D."That's right Canadians, your Food Guide, part of how we sell food in Canada, and for those who don't remember, a guide officially co-launched by our Secretary of State for Agriculture.
My plans to move however, may be premature as when my just barely 3 year old daughter heard me mention the "Give thirsty kids water" campaign shouted out with great concern,
"No! We like milk!"Guess Health Canada got to her.
Friday, September 14, 2007
John Hodgman's System for Success
Welcome new readers from Weight Wise up in Edmonton! Hope you folks are being nice to Arya.
You might not know it yet, but Fridays are different here at Weighty Matters.
Whereas the rest of the week may well involve my proverbial crying about the weighty matters of the world, Fridays are Funny Fridays.
For email subscribers I'm told that to view the Funny Friday videos, you've got to visit the actual blog.
Have a great weekend!
Oh, and here's John Hodgman from the Daily Show with his motivational power system for success.
Thursday, September 13, 2007
Quebec's Useless School Gestures
Yesterday Quebec's provincial Health Minister Philippe Couillard reported Quebec is planning to ban sugary soft drinks and junk food from schools.
La Presse newspaper even reported that poutine (french fries smothered with cheese curds and gravy) will be cut from school cafeterias.
Some brief observations:
When I was in high school at lunchtime we would run across the street to the coffee shop for donuts or to the fish and chip place for chips. Was it a coincidence that those shops were there?
Remember, Big Food is anything but stupid.
If only there were a study looking at the proximity of fast food outlets in relation to public schools.
Well guess what, there is one.
Wanna guess what the researchers found?
The study, done in Chicago, found,
"The median distance from any school in Chicago to the nearest fast-food restaurant was 0.52 km, a distance that an adult can walk in little more than 5 minutes, and 78% of schools had at least 1 fast-food restaurant within 800 m. Fast-food restaurants were statistically significantly clustered in areas within a short walking distance from schools, with an estimated 3 to 4 times as many fast-food restaurants within 1.5 km from schools than would be expected if the restaurants were distributed throughout the city in a way unrelated to school locations."Quebec and anyone else who might be listening, what we need in our schools is sensible education about calories being worked into multiple classes from a very early age (for instance math class where calories burned through exercise can be calculated and represented by potato chips consumed), the only beverages in the vending machines being zero-calorie and calorie-reduced, healthy calorie controlled school food with menu board posting of nutritional information and perhaps, like celebrity chef and school lunch reformer in the UK Jamie Oliver is suggesting, a ban on leaving school premises during lunch.
Oh, and a complete rewrite of Canada's Food Guide of course, this time without the food industry doing the rewriting.
Wednesday, September 12, 2007
Kiss menu calories goodbye (for now)

Consumers want Calories listed on menus - that's why politicians have been pushing bills through their respective government bodies to have menu board calories become a legislated affair. In the United States there are now 16 States with similar legislation in their dockets.
A few months ago New York city became the first city to enact such a law and Big Food promptly took the city to court.
Unfortunately yesterday Big Food won the first round.
A New York city judge struck down the law stating that it broke a federal law that exempted restaurants from posting calories on menus if they were posted elsewhere (like the internet), though some writers have pointed out that the judge's decision left room for a reworking of the bill to restrict action to restaurants with 10 or more locations.
The Wall Street Journal had a quote from a McDonald's spokesman named William Whitman who of course was thrilled with the court's decision because,
"posting information like this on a menu board really runs the risk of confusing customers"So just how stupid does McDonald's think you are that posting calories on menus will be confusing? Do you get confused each week when supermarket fliers report new sale prices? Does the half off rack at the clothing store give you seizures? Do you eat glue? Ummm, that 410 number beside the quarter pounder....does that mean it's $410? That sure seems like a lot for a burger.
Good news is, eventually calories will be posted on menus and menu boards. The will of the people, even the incredibly stupid people that McDonald's apparently thinks we all are, will eventually prevail. Reason being that as far as weight goes, eating without knowing calories is about as smart as shopping without knowing prices, and our eating without knowing calories is costing our governments dearly as they bleed weight related health care dollars.
Tuesday, September 11, 2007
Obesity - maybe your stomach is depressed?
This has to be one of the most ridiculous comments I've read in a long time to describe obesity and it comes from Dr. Nora Volkow the director of the U.S. National Institute on Drug Abuse.
Dr. Volkow, in an editorial published in May in the American Journal of Psychiatry says that,
"some forms of obesity are driven by an excessive motivational drive for food and should be included as a mental disorder in DSM-V"She then goes on to compare obesity with drug addiction with food of course being the drug.
Yes, let's add one more stigma to obesity and label it a mental illness and compare the obese to drug addicts. Brilliant! Helpful! Oy!
You know what should be included in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual V (the bible of psychiatric disorders) as a mental disorder? Quobesity.
Quobesity occurs when a person, just because they eat, believes that they are experts in all things obesity related. Side-effects include ridiculous editorials and quotations that often manifest as blog entries here.
The comparison of eating behaviours and drug addictions is certainly not a new one, but it does have a fatal flaw - how many folks do you know whose addictions only exist from 4pm onwards?
The vast majority of food addicts (chocoholics, carb-addicts etc) will report that their addictive behaviours and struggles with food only manifest from the mid to late afternoon onwards. It is an exceedingly small proportion of these folks who struggle all day long. The all day long folks, if they meet certain criteria, may indeed have a diagnosable psychiatric condition entitled binge eating disorder, however to reiterate, in my experience, the vast majority of bingers tend to only do so from the afternoon onward.
Those same folks, when taught to eat frequently, not skip meals or snacks and include foods helpful with hunger prevention tend to see their binging disappear, in many cases literally overnight.
If Dr. Volkow is keen to make changes for the up and coming new Diagnostic and Statistical Manual V (the bible of psychiatric disorders), might I suggest an exclusion criteria for binge eating disorder whereby the diagnosis cannot be given to an individual who skips any daytime meals or snacks.
For food addicts or binge eaters who might be reading this post - try this recipe to see if it helps minimize your addictive type behaviours. Worst case scenario you prove me wrong and you may indeed be a truly food addicted binge eater. Best case scenario, you regain control over what is most certainly a very frustrating and potentially demoralizing behaviour:
Monday, September 10, 2007
American Heart Association loves sugar and butylated hydroxytoluene
So Cheerios has recently launched a new cereal entitled, "Fruity Cheerios" and smack on the American website is its AHA "Heart Check" endorsement.
So what's a Heart Check? Well it's pretty much the same thing as the Heart and Stroke Foundation's Health Check.
According to the AHA's website,
"We know grocery shopping isn't always easy. With so many food product options, it's hard to spot healthful choices without spending a lot of time. That's why we created our Food Certification Program. We wanted consumers like you to be able to quickly look for a simple symbol that means a food product is heart-healthy.So what kind of nutritional wonder makes up Fruity Cheerios?
You can rely on our mark because the American Heart Association is your most trusted source of heart-health information. Before our mark can be displayed, a food must pass nutritional guidelines and reviews as well as meet all appropriate governmental regulations. The distinctive heart-check mark on a package assures you that a food meets criteria for heart-healthy levels of fat, saturated fat and cholesterol for healthy people over age 2."
Well each serving has over 2 teaspoons of sugar made up from 4 different sources:
In a cup per cup comparison with Froot Loops, Fruity Cheerios only has 1 gram less sugar and 7 fewer calories.
What else is in Fruity Cheerios? Well like Froot Loops it's also got such yummies as Red 40, Yellow 6, Blue 1 and butylated hydroxytoluene (listed as BHT on the box).
What's BHT?
Well BHT is produced by an alkylation reaction of p-cresol with isobutylene and it's used not only as a food additive, but also in cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, jet fuels, rubber, petroleum products, and embalming fluid (according to Wikipedia). As a food additive BHT has been banned in Japan, Romania, Sweden, England and Australia and the Center for Science in the Public Interest recommends it be avoided whenever possible.
So the American Heart Association basically recommends that you feed your toddlers Froot Loops with a questionable food additive for breakfast?
Fantastic.
I wonder how long before it gets a Heart and Stroke Foundation Health Check?
Friday, September 07, 2007
Thursday, September 06, 2007
Canada Fails its Children Yet Again
This past Friday our government quietly snuck out their official response to the Healthy Weights, Healthy Kids report that summarized the already politicized "findings" of the Standing Committee on Health.
If you recall, I was kindly asked to testify before that Committee regarding the shortcomings of Canada's new Food Guide.
Previously I had criticized the report itself for being toothless, however if the report was toothless than the official government response lacks even gums.
The original report had recommended:
The official response?
A 31 page document that tried to highlight all of the great work the government's already doing (so great that obesity rates rise year by year and no real dollars are being spent to do anything about it) but plainly avoided making any true commitments to any firm changes.
Bill Jeffery, national coordinator for Canada's arm of the Center for Science in the Public Interest summarized it well in his press release,
"after studying the report for five months, Minister of Health Tony Clement meekly committed mainly just to further research and consultations, leaving the impression that the government hasn’t done its homework or is stalling to curry favour with key food industry players."I guess our industry-based, rather than evidence-based Food Guide is here to stay, as are trans-fats in our food supply, fast food commercials targeting children too young to discern the difference between truth and advertising, misleading food labels, poor school nutrition and a lack of calorie information on food menus.
Wonder how much money the government just wasted on the months of testimony, the creation of the report and the official response of self-validated, misguided, inaction?
Wednesday, September 05, 2007
J. K. Rowling is a big, "fat" hypocrite

So I'm a big Harry Potter fan and have read all of J.K. Rowling's books therein.
I've also recently visited J.K. Rowling's blog where she has posted a rant about fat stereotyping and thinness.
In a nutshell her rant involves how awful it is that society uses the word "fat" as an insult, how society is too focused on weight as a whole and how much she likes Pink's latest single Stupid Girls which according to J.K.,
"satirises the talking toothpicks held up to girls as role models".She reports that she finds the "fat insult" to be,
"strange and sick."and then she then goes on to blast skinny folks in general stating in reference to her daughters,
"I've got two daughters who will have to make their way in this skinny-obsessed world, and it worries me, because I don't want them to be empty-headed, self-obsessed, emaciated clones; I'd rather they were independent, interesting, idealistic, kind, opinionated, original, funny – a thousand things, before 'thin'."So basically J.K.'s rant places her vehemently against the use of the word "fat" as an insult, and clearly demonstrates her willingness to wield the word "thin" as one with "thin" for her denoting empty-headedness, self-obsession, lack of originality and dullness.
Hypocritical behaviour all by itself, for if you are against the notion of using excess weight as an insult it should follow that you'd be against using lack of weight as an insult too.
All the more hypocritical though for the author of the Harry Potter series to complain about fat stereotyping as throughout her series she milked those same "strange and sick" fat insults for all they were worth in her portrayal of Dudley Dursley, Harry's fat cousin and muggle nemesis.
So what fat insults does she cultivate in her books?
That fat people are lazy, stupid, gluttonous, angry, will-less, pigs.
Think I'm exaggerating?
Here are some quotes from her books:
"Dudley looked a lot like Uncle Vernon. He had a large, pink face, not much neck, small watery blue eyes and thick, blond hair that lay smoothly on his thick, fat head....Harry often said that Dudley looked like a pig in a wig."She also had Dudley eating candy dropped on the floor, growing wider than he is tall, and to really hammer home the pig analogy, Hagrid, a wizard grows him a pig's tail,
- Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone
"Aunt Petunia obviously scented danger too, because she said quickly, 'And we'll buy you another two presents while we're out today. How's that popkin?' Two more presents. Is that all right?' Dudley thought for a moment. It looked like hard work. Finally he said slowly, 'So I'll have thirty... thirty...' 'Thirty-nine, sweetums,' said Aunt Petunia. 'Oh.' Dudley sat down heavily and grabbed the nearest parcel."
- Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone
his piggy little eyes [were] fixed on the [television] screen and his five chins wobbling as he ate continuously”
-Harry Potter and the prisoner of Azkaban
"Dudley looked furious and sulky, and somehow seemed to be taking up even more space than usual."
-Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
"Dudley had reached roughly the size and weight of a young killer whale"
-Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
"Dudley who had already finished his own grapefruit quarter was eyeing Harry's with a very sour look in his piggly little eyes"
-Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
"Dudley was dancing on the spot with his hands clasped over his fat bottom, howling in pain. When he turned his back on them, Harry saw a curly pig's tail poking through a hole in his trousers....Meant ter turn him into a pig, but I suppose he was so much like a pig anyway there wasn't much left ter do."J.K., I love your books, and agree with your rant that society is far too quick to judge on the basis of weight. Such a shame that despite a clearly tremendous imagination and a brilliant gift for words, that you've decided that while "fat" insults are "sick", "thin" insults are acceptable. It's also a shame that given how self-reportedly anti-fat-insults you are, that you utilized classic fat stereotyping to help sell over 400 million copies of your books and in so doing helped to solidify those same fat stereotypes in an entire global generation of children.
- Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone
J.K., you are a big, "fat" hypocrite.
Tuesday, September 04, 2007
Health Check blesses God Sugar

My morning paper yesterday was sheathed in an advertisement from Welch's Grape Juice.
There were two parts to the ad.
The first part detailed new Welch's sugar reduced grape juices, while the second extolled the fact that the Heart and Stroke Foundation's Health Check has been applied to their 100% grape juice.
So let me ask you some questions.
Q. Do you think Coca Cola is a healthy beverage?
A. Of course not, it's high in calories and sugar with no nutritional benefits.
Q. How about if I took Coca Cola and added in some vitamins?
A. No, still not healthy - lots of sugar, and lots of other preservative type stuff.
Q. How about then I just take a glass of pure spring water, add to it 10.5 teaspoons of sugar and then a few vitamins - would that be a healthy beverage?
A. 10.5 teaspoons of sugar in water a healthy beverage? You've got to be kidding me. You could put in all of the vitamins in the world, drinking a cup with 10.5 teaspoons of sugar simply isn't healthy.
Q. Then how come the Heart and Stroke Foundation's Health Check program has endorsed Welch's 100% grape juice?
A. Because Health Check doesn't care about calories and apparently doesn't bother to critically appraise or apply sound science to their nutritional criteria.
Welch's 100% red grape juice has 42.5 grams of sugar per glass and contains 170 calories per serving. That's 10.5 teaspoons of sugar per day, is glass per glass almost double the calories and sugar of a glass of Coca Cola, and if you drink a glass daily (or worse yet, give it to your children) that's almost 18lbs worth of grape juice calories per year.
Sounds super healthy to me.
But wait, there's more!
Welch's has come up with a calorie reduced version of its grape juice. It's partially sweetened with Splenda and it has only 70 calories per glass and only 4 teaspoons of sugar.
Sounds a lot better right? Maybe that should get the Health Check rather than the 10.5 teaspoons of sugar and double the calories and sugar of Coca Cola version right?
Nope.
Health Check's criteria require that juices all be 100% juice so the lower calorie light versions do not qualify.
When are the Heart and Stroke Foundation's dietitians (and Health Canada's for that matter) going to recognize calories as a valuable nutritional component, and when are health professionals finally going to admit that a glass of sugar is a glass of sugar, whether god made the sugar or man made the sugar drinking a glass of sugar with vitamins in it is NOT a healthy choice.
(Sorry for the late post, my home internet was down)
Monday, September 03, 2007
Labour Day Video Post
So today's likely going to be a lazy day for most folk.
If anyone's got an hour to spend, here's Charlie Rose's excellent recent round table on obesity.
Friday, August 31, 2007
Stephen Colbert vs. nutrition
It's always nice when Funny Fridays meets nutrition.
Here are two of my heroes - Stephen Colbert "interviewing" the head of the Center for Science in the Public Interest Michael Jacobson.
Can you guess which one of them said,
"Ice cream’s like medicine, it’s not even food.....it’s an antidepressant"Have a great weekend!
Thursday, August 30, 2007
Performance Chocolate Bars?
So apparently now Hershey's is marketing OhHenry! bars as performance enhancing.
Their new bar, OhHenry! Pro is being promoted for both its protein content and its consequent great fit as a sports enhancement.
Television commercials have folks eating OhHenry! Pro bars suddenly gaining great strength and agility and of course are aimed at teens with their music and content (skateboarding and cycling).
So what is in this rocket propelled chocolate bar?
320 Calories, 21grams of fat (6grams saturated), 5 teaspoons of sugar and 12 grams of protein.
Or to put it differently, pretty much exactly the same stuff as is in a regular Oh Henry! bar just with double the protein.
Wanna know some secrets?
Protein won't make you fast.
Calories will eventually make you slow.
Hershey's marketers apparently lack scruples.
[Hat tip to Rob our fitness director for bringing me a bar]
Wednesday, August 29, 2007
Did Big Milk Lie to the FTC?
"You don't have to be a hero to feel invincible. That's why I drink milk. The protein helps build muscle and some studies suggest teens who choose it tend to be leaner. Cheers to that"So I don't know if you remember, but I sure do - the FTC challenged Big Milk to prove their weight loss claims and of course since the studies Big Milk based their claims off of were all pretty much relegated to very small experiments done out of a lab funded by Big Milk where the professor involved has an actual patent on weight loss claims related to milk consumption, Big Milk reported that they would back off the weight loss advertising until the claims were in fact more substantiated.
That was back in May and then Lydia Parnes, the Director of the Federal Trade Commission's Bureau of Consumer Protection reported milk producers and processors had agreed to change the advertisements,
"until further research provides stronger, more conclusive evidence of an association between dairy consumption and weight loss."Now I suppose the word "leaner" may be a means to circumvent the FTC's concerns, but frankly to me the word leaner certainly still implies weight loss.
I read the medical literature pretty carefully and milk is no where near being proven to be a helpful weight loss aid and furthermore no where near being proven to possess any magical lean body mass increasing properties.
Once again, shame on you Big Milk.
FTC, where the heck are you guys in terms of following up on these ridiculously misleading and scientifically unfounded claims and advertisments - advertisements that now directly target children and teens?
Tuesday, August 28, 2007
Should you send your child to Weight Watchers?

In the comments on the Fat Camp post yesterday was the question, "Why not send a child to Weight Watchers?".
There's some overlap between Fat Camp and Weight Watchers and it has to do with the attitudes and thoughts cultivated in children who have been effectively told they're too fat and that they must lose weight, and that they need professional help.
Putting aside the question of whether or not Weight Watchers or Fat Camps teach healthy weight management practices, my belief is that for most children instead of cultivating healthy behaviours, Fat Camps, Weight Watchers and other direct weight loss interventions end up cultivating tremendously negative emotions, guilt, self-doubt, low self-esteem, sadness, and in most cases, ultimately failure.
My belief quite simply is that unless the child has a major weight related medical condition that requires treatment, that weight loss education should be relegated to the parents and not to the child.
Furthermore I'd state that any weight loss intervention for children that does not explicitly involve the parents is ill informed and worth avoiding.
To illustrate some of what I'm talking about, Rudd Sound Bites back in June posted a fantastic essay by Marjorie Galler who herself had once attended Fat Camp. The essay is a fantastic glimpse into what goes on at Fat Camp. It's a must read - click here.
Any readers out there go to Weight Watchers (or other weight loss program) when they were kids? Any of you remember how it made you feel and whether or not it fostered healthy attitudes and behaviours about weight? I'd love to hear about it in the comments.
Monday, August 27, 2007
Generation XXL Documentary Review

Don't ever say I don't listen to my readers.
Long term reader Geordie asked me last week if I could watch the documentary Generation XXL and comment therein - here are my thoughts.
The documentary is about a group of children from Nova Scotia being sent to a sort of short term fat camp - only it's not exactly a fat camp and I'll get to that a bit later.
The documentary starts with their current lifestyles and from the beginning it's obvious that their environments' are far from ideal food and weight wise.
Of the 4 featured children, Kat, Greg, Raya and Vincent, 3 explicitly reported not eating breakfast.
Kat's mother when confronted by Kat who said she was not supportive pointed out that since Kat was 12 she had been paying for and taking her to Weight Watchers meetings. This same parent in an earlier scene spends time harping on Kat's choice of french fries as opposed to salad.
Vincent goes for dinner at his father's house and either for a snack or for dinner his father made 6 Pillsbury dough puffs and sat down with Vincent to eat them.
Greg's mother comes home and it's dark outside and Greg hasn't had dinner yet and presumably is pretty darn hungry.
Raya's mother admits to providing her with whatever foods she wants and that she herself has a difficult time with food in terms of using it for comfort and pleasure. There's also a great scene of a school dance for Raya where on the dance floor is an at least 8 foot tall poster of what I can only presume to be a dance sponsor featuring 3 gigantic O'Henry chocolate bars.
So the kids get packed up and off to a place called the, "Fit Intervention Program" which according to the Generation XXL website,
"Its primary goal is to create a context that supports overall healthy living that nurtures individual strength."It's definitely not a typical fat camp as from the documentary it became quite clear the goal of this immersive short term experience for the kids was not weight loss, but rather self-esteem building.
They were taught to cook by chefs, did art therapy course, did have some food instruction (and unfortunately were taught Canada's Food Guide) and were instructed to exercise.
I had mixed feelings about the camp experience. They did not appear to have been taught anything at all about weight management, though that may be due to editing. I mean if you're already getting sent to a place to discuss the impact of weight on yourself as a person, you should probably be taught about calories, hunger prevention and such, but really, I didn't see any of this. They were also seen by an exercise specialist who provided them with pedometers and the unreasonable goal of trying to get 12,000 steps per day. A much better goal would have been to encourage them to get as many steps as they could enjoy so they wouldn't feel like failures when they resumed their real lives and didn't see numbers approaching 12,000.
I absolutely detested the part of the movie where they spent time giving the kids scary articles about risks of weight on cardiovascular disease and cancer. These kids felt plenty of guilt on their own about their weight before being hit with the articles, and given that there was no apparent weight management instructions provided to them other than follow the Food Guide and walk like crazy, I felt the scare tactics were really counter productive and unnecessary.
What I loved about the camp experience was the fact that the kids were really forced to confront how their weight has made them feel but in a manner that empowered them to try to break free from the notion that their weight defines them.
I think the most grievous omission of the camp experience was that it was for the kids and not the parents. Kat's mother should have been taught that the absolute worst thing she could do for Kat would be to ride her about her food and that sending a child to Weight Watchers may well have long term impact on that child's relationship with weight, self esteem and body image. Vincent's dad should have been taught about calories and healthy eating. Raya's mom could have been taught about the role of hunger prevention in reducing the drive to eat for comfort and Greg's mom could have been taught about the importance of eating regularity.
All of the parents should have been taught to live the lives they want their children to live.
By not addressing these kids' parents, and by not really providing the kids with any real weight management tools at best this camp experience provided the kids with improved self esteem and a new outlook on life, but at worst served as the basis for yet another major weight related disappointment.
If I were to be involved in a camp like this it would be with the explicit requirement of a parallel camp for parents where they're taught how to lead by example rather than by criticism or edict.
At the end of the documentary we're given a few telling glimpses into how little these kids learned about actual weight management.
Greg got a job, lost 10lbs and then reported while grabbing his stomach,
"I might have to get liposuction to get this out"Vincent blamed habit and said that he's not going to change.
Kat lost 8.2lbs and reported being discouraged because she hasn't lost as much as she'd hoped. She then told the camera she's going to live off frozen fruit juice ice cubes and watermelon for the summer while her mother stood by apparently silently approving.
I give the documentary a B+ because it was compelling to watch, but the content as far as helping these kids out I'd give a D.
Friday, August 24, 2007
Dancing with the King
Ok, so it's a bit creepy.
Jib Jab, a longstanding web animation site has created a means to animate you.
My brother-in-law says that watching my video creeped him out.
It made me laugh.
Just click on the link at the bottom of this post and you can creep out your own brothers-in-law.
One note - when "creating" my video I realized that there's a dramatic shortage of female fast food mascots - I couldn't think of any. What's up with that? The only one I could think of was the little girl from Wendy's but then again, they never use her to sell food.
Have a great weekend!
Star in Your Own JibJab! It's Free!
Thursday, August 23, 2007
"How to get fat without even trying"
The media is awash about different causes of obesity. Just last week we were bombarded with reports on how diet foods cause childhood obesity. While I was planning to talk about how ridiculously the media handled that particular story, instead I've found something else that I thought was more worth posting. It's Peter Jennings' fantastic 2004 report "How to get fat without even trying", on the role North American governments and the food industry play in the explosive growth of obesity.
Thanks to Dr. Marion Nestle who is the Paulette Goddard Professor of Nutrition, Food Studies, and Public Health at New York University whose fantastic book Food Politics apparently inspired Peter Jennings to do the piece and thanks to Dr. Nestle as well for posting a link to the piece on her fabulous blog two days ago.
It's a long video (10 mins).
It's not funny.
It's a great watch.
Tuesday, August 21, 2007
Heart and Stroke's heart-on for refined white flour, ground beef and salt
Here's another example of why you shouldn't blindly trust the Heart and Stroke's Health Check to steer you to "healthy" choices.
Stouffer's meat lasagna!
Given it's new status as a Health Check'ed item that would mean that according to the Heart and Stroke's dietitians refined white flour + ground beef + almost a day's worth of sodium = super-duper healthy!
What? You think there's something not particularly healthy about refined white flours? Could it be their clear cut contribution to the development of metabolic syndrome and diabetes? Beef not good for you? Carcinogenic? Increases the risk of diabetes? Salt increase blood pressure? Increased blood pressure increases the risk of heart attacks and strokes?
You'd think that perhaps the dietitians of the Heart and Stroke Foundation would know these facts - after all, they're dietitians and they work for the Heart and Stroke Foundation and doubtlessly they should know all about the dietary contributions to heart disease and stroke, right?
Apparently not.
Stouffer's Meat Lasagna where the flour is "semolina wheat flour" (white, white, white), the beef is "cooked ground beef" (wanna bet it wasn't extra lean ground beef?), and the sodium content is 950mg, a short hop away from what a recent Heart and Stroke Foundation press release recommended as a total daily allowance of 1,260mg now has a Health Check.
I know, I know, it's probably better than non-health checked lasagnas, but to endorse an unhealthy option as healthy simply because it's healthier than some other options doesn't make it a healthy choice and certainly shouldn't buy it an explicit endorsement from the Heart and Stroke Foundation.
Stouffer's of course is milking it for all it's worth on the product's webpage,
"Look for the Health Check logo on STOUFFER'S meals – it's like shopping with a dietitian from the Heart and Stroke Foundation."I can't really blame them, after all they paid the Heart and Stroke Foundation's Health Check good money to apparently sell out.
and
"Enjoy all the taste that’s made STOUFFER’S Lasagna the #1 selling lasagna in Canada for the past year – especially now it’s got the Health Check mark."
Posted by
Yoni Freedhoff, MD
at
7:45 am
Labels: Beef, Eating, Health Check, Heart and Stroke Foundation, Sodium
Fat March: TV Review

Monday nights there's a new obesity reality show on ABC called, "Fat March".
The premise is simple. 12 obese Americans join two personal trainers and "march" 570 miles trying to lose weight. There's money involved of course. $1.2 million dollars to be split 12 ways at the end. The catch? Anytime a person is voted off or quits everyone's prize money goes down by $10,000.
So how do I summarize this monstrosity?
Take every stereotype you can think of about overweight and obesity, roll it into one, mix it with two wooden, idiotic trainers, shake, add inappropriate exercise and voila both you and the cast members get to go to the hospital. You, for your new found brain damage and the cast members for the myriad of injuries the show has cultivated.
Yesterday's episode had marchers calling each other derogatory obesity slurs, had a big plate of doughnuts that the marchers were supposed to "resist", had one marcher try to eat a doughnut off the ground, had shots emphasizing how whiny, lazy and will-less the marchers were, had the second of thus far two emergency room visits due to poorly designed exercise and over-training, had marchers whinging about how much they missed food and eating, and had a preview of future weeks' episodes where at least one more of the marchers is taken to hospital and told that he'll need knee surgery.
What upsets me more is the fact that the show is setting the marchers up for failure. They are being taught a ridiculously non-sustainable lifestyle and are being given the expectation that they'll lose weight, get rich, go home and stay skinny when in reality they're just on a crash diet where the word crash is quite apropos - people tend to get injured in crashes.
Unless these marchers plan to keep marching for 4-8 hours a day and continue adhering to a blindly restrictive low calorie diet, the weight they lose will come back as soon as they revert back to their old lifestyles which I would predict will happen the very moment the show is over because the lifestyle the show has given them no one in their right mind would want to live.
Bottom line: The show is awful. It will not only not help educate you in means to manage weight but it will promote all that is wrong about "dieting" as truth and do so with cameras whose jobs it apparently is to perpetuate and exploit cultural obesity stereotypes.
I give it an F.
Monday, August 20, 2007
How much weight will you lose with a gastric bypass?
I'm not a surgeon and therefore I don't perform gastric bypasses, but I sure get that question a lot from folks who are interested in having one.
Came across an interesting report on a paper that was presented by Dr. Daniel Leslie at the 89th meeting of the Endocrine Society. The paper reported on a number of variables that predicted bariatric surgical success and they came up with an "equation" that you simply plug into to answer the question of how much weight a gastric bypass patient can expect to lose.
Ready for it? Here's the equation,
"Weight loss in lbs = [(age in years) x -1.79] + [(preoperative weight in lbs) x 0.36] + [(1 if patient if African-American, 0 if European-American) x -16.56] + [(1 for peripheral weight distribution, 0 for central) x 7.45] + [(1 for type 2 diabetes, 0 for no diabetes) x -7.28] + [(1 for obstructive sleep apnea, 0 for no sleep apnea) x 7.15] + 106.63"Of course there are many other variables.
Basically the surgery provides patients with a tremendous anatomical advantage for weight loss. The average patient's weight loss may be describable on the basis of the equation, but you need not be an average patient.
What the equation doesn't and cannot account for are the personal intangibles. The changes a person makes to their lifestyle will also have a tremendous impact on their weight loss. Some patients tend to take gastric bypass as a fresh start of sorts and get more involved in things like exercise and healthy eating. In my experience, those patients tend to lose more.
Just in case you've forgotten my take on bariatric surgery I'll remind you. I tend to call it, "a fabulous last resort".
UPDATE: My original post was off by a factor of 100, the new equation ought to work
Friday, August 17, 2007
Toughest Interview Ever
Today for Funny Friday is the toughest interview ever.
I learned two things from this video:
1. What the word Scombridae means
2. Pre-interviews are good ideas for television producers
Have a great weekend!
Thursday, August 16, 2007
Horseman of the Nutritional Apocalypse
I had no idea that this existed.
A patient of mine returned from a trip to Syracuse where she kept on getting asked the following question when she ordered meals in restaurants,
"Would you like that smothered?"She didn't know what the waiters were talking about so she of course asked what "smothered" meant.
Apparently smothered means that for an additional dollar or so you can have your whole meal "smothered" in smokey bacon, fresh sauteed mushrooms & Monterey Jack cheese.
At Fresno's this privilege will cost your $1.19 extra.
And yet people go on and on about the "mystery" of why the world is gaining weight so quickly.
Any readers out there with smothering stories?
Wednesday, August 15, 2007
Tim Horton's Liquid Big Mac
A Big Mac has 540 calories, 10 grams of saturated fat and 0.5 grams of trans fat.
What wonderful new Tim Horton's beverage has more calories, more saturated fat and more trans fat than the Big Mac?
The winner is, Tim Hortons 18oz Butter Caramel Iced Capp Supreme!
With 560 calories, 17 grams of saturated fat and 1 gram of trans fat it's a tall, cold glass of why it is we absolutely need calories posted on menu boards.
Hat tip to CSPI for raising the red flag.
Tuesday, August 14, 2007
A Calorie's a Calorie, or is it?
Certainly that's what we preach. A calorie's a calorie - if you were to eat the exact same number of calories daily it wouldn't matter where those calories came from they'd have the same effect on your weight.
Or would they?
I'm very comfortable saying I'm wrong, and while I'm not quite willing to do that in the a calorie is a calorie case yet, I'm a bit closer today due to an article I read yesterday in the journal Obesity.
The article looked at 42 green monkeys who were followed for 6 years. They were fed one of two diets that were designed to "maintain" their study starting weight by providing them each with 70 Calories per kg of green monkey weight. What varied in these diets was the percentage of fat that came from trans fats with one group of monkeys getting 8% of their fat from trans fat sources while the other group had less than 1% of fat from trans fat sources.
Otherwise, the sample diets were pretty much the same.
The results were surprising. The trans fat group's weight increased by roughly 7% while the other group gained less than 2% with the trans fat group having gained more fat intra-abdominally (the less healthy place to gain it). The researchers also found that post meal insulin levels in the trans fat group were 3x higher than in the non-trans fat group and there was a reduction seen in tissue biopsy of the trans fat group's insulin receptors' abilities to trigger a response.
The authors conclude that trans fats are in fact independently associated with both weight gain and the preferential distribution of weight intra-abdominally resulting in an impairment of glucose tolerance which in turn is of course a risk factor for the development of type II diabetes.
This was definitely a neat study and while I'm not yet ready to stop telling people a calorie's a calorie, I'm eager to see some studies that try to tease out whether this is applicable to humans or just to green monkeys.
To be sure however, this study is yet one more piece of damning evidence against the inclusion of trans-fat in our diets.
Monday, August 13, 2007
Do-it-yourself Gatorade
Can't take the credit for this one - it's from a guy whose got a blog named "Yaniverse" but unfortunately he's apparently locked his blog to registered users only.
Ages ago I bookmarked a do-it-yourself recipe that he posted for a Gatorade/Energy Drink substitute. Thanks to the magic of the internet, even though my recipe link no longer worked, I was able to find it online in someone's Google notebook.
First I'll give you his recipe (makes roughly 2L) and then some brief comments:
2 Tea BagsI know, my first reaction was, "Isn't that just tea?", and frankly it is, but the thing is, you don't need to buy fancy calorie laden energy drinks to help with sports hydration just like you don't have to buy fancy energy bars either - a whole wheat tortilla, smeared with some peanut butter and wrapped around a banana's a cheap and delicious alternative to a Powerbar anyday.
6 level teaspoon sugar (24 grams)
A pinch of salt (0.5 grams)
2 oz lemon juice (about 55 grams)
30 oz boiling water
Contains:
100 calories
200 mg Sodium
60mg of Potassium (from the lemon juice)
Caffeine varies, est 100mg-200mg caffeine (depending on the tea used and infusion duration)
Estimated Cost:
Lemon juice: $0.10
2 Tea Bags: $0.06
Sugar, Salt, water, etc: negligible
If I remember correctly from Yani's readers' comments (before he locked his blog), obviously the type of tea matters dramatically in regards to taste and according to Yani, you can double the lemon juice if you want. I would suspect that if it's not sweet enough, you can either increase the sugar or add some Splenda - if your activity is longer than 45 minutes straight it may be worth adding more sugar as your body will need the fuel.
Yani, if you're reading, I'd love to link and credit you more formally, but I couldn't figure out how to find you through Blogger.
Update: Thanks to eagle-eyed reader Robert who calculated that 0.5grams of salt would contain roughly 200mg of sodium. Have changed the above to reflect same.
Friday, August 10, 2007
Conan meets Industrial Light and Magic
Wow, a lot of angry posts this week.
To try to sooth my frayed nerves I did some Conan surfing on youtube and found a great clip of him visiting George Lucas' Industrial Light and Magic (the special effects folks).
If you've never seen C3P0 drunk, it may be a worthwhile click.
Have a great weekend!
(New subscribers to my email feed - if you want to see the clip apparently you have to visit the blog)
Thursday, August 09, 2007
Eat Stupid!
My readers in Ontario may be familiar with the Eat Smart! Ontario's Healthy Restaurant Program.
I think it should be called, "Eat Stupid!".
Here's what their website says it's for,
"Through its "Award of Excellence" program, Eat Smart! Ontario’s Healthy Restaurant Program offers recognition to Ontario restaurants that meet exceptional standards in nutrition, food safety and smoke-free dining. This program was developed in partnership with the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long Term Care; Heart and Stroke Foundation of Ontario; Canadian Cancer Society (Ontario Division); Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs; local public health units; heart health programs; the food service industry and consumers."So what do you think most folks will think about the restaurants who meet the Eat Smart! criteria? I think most folks will think they're healthy restaurants to go to - restaurants whose health is endorsed by folks like the Heart and Stroke Foundation and our government's Ministry of Health.
In fact, that's what the Eat Smart! people themselves say will happen in their own promotion of their website,
"In addition to the free promotion available to you and your establishment, there are other important benefits:So why am I calling it Eat Stupid!? Isn't this a great idea?You will strengthen your image in your community as a health-conscious restaurant. You will belong to a province-wide program endorsed by both the Canadian Cancer Society (Ontario Division) and the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Ontario."
Nope.
Let's go through the basic criteria for being included as an Eat Smart! restaurant and being endorsed by the Heart and Stroke Foundation and the Ministry of Health:
It requires that on the menu, anywhere, regardless of what else is on the menu, that:
- There is a single whole grain product OR a source of fibre and all comers need apply: 400 Calories bagels, 450 Calorie "low fat" (read high sugar) muffins, pizza crust (they actually think pizza crust qualifies?), pancakes, cereal, pasta, rice.... basically anything.
- There are at least 6 choices of vegetable or fruit. Including, amazingly, vegetable sandwich toppings (the lettuce or tomato on my sandwich counts as a vegetable?) and juice count too.
- Milk is available as a beverage
- There are 1-3 meat options cooked in a "healthy" way which basically includes every manner of cooking with the exception of deep frying. That would therefore include carcinogenic broiling and trans-fat creating pan frying.
- The availability of a "healthier" dessert choice yet frozen yogurt, milk puddings, "low fat" muffins, crepes and waffles count and I certainly wouldn't count any of those as particularly "healthy".
- If a children's menu is offered, milk and juice must be options and there has to be a vegetable or fruit included.
What this means for the restaurants is that they get to brag about how healthy they are (they get a decal for the door and I believe brochures for inside), they get included on the Eat Smart! brochure that's often handed out by well-intentioned but misinformed health professionals, they get a tacit endorsement by folks like the Heart and Stroke Foundation, and they get to push their high calorie, high sodium, high fat, nutritionally deficient food at you under the guise of health because you see, Eat Smart! doesn't bother to identify the items on the menus that it thought were healthy and actually when you get right down to it, Eat Smart!'s criteria don't even require the availability of healthy meals, just the availability, somewhere on the menu, of healthy ingredients.
Canadians need to be steered to specifically healthy menu choices, not to restaurants where in their kitchens somewhere or other there is a healthy food or two.
The fact that Denny's serves milk, uses parsley, lettuce and tomatoes as garnishes and places an orange wedge as an accompaniment does not make their Fabulous French Toast Platter replete with 1261 calories, 30grams of saturated fat and 2,495mg of sodium a healthy choice.
What a clear cut example of where best intentions are definitely not good enough and maybe even worse than nothing.
Posted by
Yoni Freedhoff, MD
at
5:17 am
Labels: Government, Heart and Stroke Foundation, Restaurants, Sodium
Wednesday, August 08, 2007
McCarrots?
No, McCarrots don't exist, but if they did, you're kids would be more likely to eat them.
In a study published this month in the Archives of Pediatric Adolescent Medicine we can see proof of the vulnerability of children to advertising.
The study had children taste 5 pairs of identical foods and beverages in packaging from McDonald's and in matched but unbranded packaging and were then asked which one tasted better.
Bet you can see where this is going.
The participants by the way were between the ages of 3 and 5 years old. The foods were McDonald's hamburgers, McDonald's fries, a Chicken McNugget, 3 ounces of 1% milk and baby carrots.
Yes, even carrots wrapped up in McDonald's wrappers were rated as tasting better by this group of children.
As far as I'm concerned there should absolutely be a ban on advertising targeting children and given a child's proven inability to discern truth from advertising that ban should extend beyond simply junk food advertisers but rather to all advertisers. This elegant study certainly confirms that need.
It also makes me wish McDonald's sold baby carrots.
Tuesday, August 07, 2007
The Primary Cause of Obesity
I'm constantly amazed by quotes detailing how complicated it is to pinpoint blame in the obesity epidemic. In my mind, it's the treatment that's complicated, while the problem, well I think it's pretty obvious.
As everyone on the planet knows, the world is getting heavier - fast. So what's changed?
Have our genetics changed in the past 100 years? Of course not.
Is there a terrible virus, bacteria, fungus or parasite that we can blame? Nope.
Is it genetically modified crops, or pesticides or us using the air conditioner more frequently? Good grief no.
So what's changed in the past 100 years? For lack of a better term - our foodscape.
Sure genetics, hormones, learned behaviours and maybe even the temperature you set your thermostat on have a bearing on weight, so do thousands of other variables, but without any question whatsoever the environment is to blame.
I read an article yesterday in a Big Food tradezine that had a fabulous quote by a food marketing big wig named Harry Balzer (I swear I didn't make up the name),
"Americans now use restaurants like their parents traditionally used grocery stores"This particular article looked at how our use of restaurants has changed in the past 50 years. It stated:
To live in 2007 and maintain a healthy body weight while eating out an average of 208 meals outside of the home would border on the impossible. The calories associated with restaurant portions and foods are ridiculously high and while certainly it is possible to make some healthy or lower calorie restaurant choices, eating out 4 times per week, you're almost certainly going to make quite a few that are less than ideal. Furthermore you're also going to train your eye to expect the restaurant sized portions that we have seen evolve over the past 4 decades.
Now I'm not blaming solely restaurants, I'm blaming food in general because that is what has changed - how we eat has changed, where we eat has changed, what we eat has changed, how often we eat has changed, and why we eat has changed.
Rich Rojko, a manager at the high end Ruth's Chris steakhouse chain that now offers takeout had this to say,
"Eating has become something that people do while they're doing something else."Indeed.
Monday, August 06, 2007
Don't Eat at Wendy's Part II
Imagine my surprise.
Wendy's, the fast food chain that is refusing to comply with New York city's new calorie disclosure requirements, the chain that insults the intelligence of consumers by reporting that their online nutritional posting of calories applies to everywhere but New York and who apparently feels you're too stupid to understand a menu board that includes calories and prices, has apparently also refused to comply with New York's trans-fat free laws.
Last week the Center for Science in the Public Interest released a report detailing their study of New York fries. Through an independent laboratory analysis they demonstrated that McDonald's fries were virtually trans-fat free, Burger King's had 3.3grams and Wendy's topped their charts at 3.7grams - almost twice the daily recommended limit.
CSPI does give credit where credit is due and reports that the fries in New York, even those from Wendy's, are lower than the trans-fat content of fries fried by Wendy's in every other city in North America, but where CSPI has difficulty is the claims made by Wendy's website,
"Depending on the serving size, trans fats in French fry offerings will range from zero to 0.5 grams."So basically Wendy's lies to you and apparently thinks you're stupid.
Stop giving them your money.
Friday, August 03, 2007
Mmmmmm Catnip
Sorry for the late posting. Probably will be late on Monday too.
Today for Funny Friday - Catnip.
Have a great weekend!
Thursday, August 02, 2007
Don't eat at Wendy's

Regular readers here will know that in NYC Big Food is fighting legislation requiring them to put calories on menu boards.
Regular readers will also know one of Big Food's "arguments" is that it's toooooooo complicated to put calories on menu boards in a manner that would be both easy for consumers to understand and in a manner that wouldn't clog up the boards.
As part of the case, the Center for Science in the Public Interest had its artists create a rendition of what a Wendy's menu board might look like with calories on it. Click the picture above and you tell me if it's too complicated or too cluttered.
Anyhow, Wendy's sent out cease and desist letters to the court and CSPI stating that CSPI is misrepresenting their menu and breaking trademarks by providing it to the court.
This is the same Wendy's who has a ridiculous disclaimer on their own website that states that their Calorie information is not available in NYC with the hope that this will allow them to slime their way through a wormhole in the existing legislation that limits required calorie menu board laws to those restaurants who have pre-existing nutritional information,
"We regret that Wendy's cannot provide product calorie information to residents or customers in New York City. The New York City Department of Health passed a regulation requiring restaurants that already provide calorie information to post product calories on their menu boards -- using the same type size as the product listing.I love the made to order argument as well given that Subway has already complied with the regulation and they're as made to order as you get in fast food. Talk about misrepresenting!
We fully support the intent of this regulation; however, since most of our food is made-to-order, there isn't enough room on our existing menu boards to comply with the regulation. We have for years provided complete nutritional information on posters inside the restaurant and on our website. To continue to provide caloric information to residents and customers of our New York City restaurants on our website and on our nutritional posters would subject us to this regulation. As a result, we will no longer provide caloric information to residents and customers of our New York City restaurants."
My recommendation - vote with your mouth. There are plenty of fast food outfits out there. Stop giving your money to one that apparently thinks you're stupid (too stupid apparently to discern between the price and the calories on a menu item), tries to weasel it's way out of adhering to the law and then tries to legally muscle out the non-profit good guys.
Don't eat at Wendy's.
(To see more "doctored" and "misrepresented" menus, including Starbucks and McDonald's at CSPI head over here.)
