Wednesday, April 23, 2008

More Canadian Health Hypocrisy

Four days ago, Tony Clement, Canada's Minister of Health announced that the Government of Canada was calling on an immediate ban on the sale of bisphenol-A containing bottles in Canada.

Why?

Well there have been some studies that suggest that there may be some risk to bisphenol-A, especially with newborns.

But I think the real reason why is because politically it's easy to do.

Certainly the science isn't there yet, and of course the government knows that too. Here's a quote from their own press release,

"The scientists concluded in this assessment that bisphenol A exposure to newborns and infants is below levels that may pose a risk"
But they want to be prudent. Here's Tony Clement on the matter,
"We have immediately taken action on bisphenol A, because we believe it is our responsibility to ensure families, Canadians and our environment are not exposed to a potentially harmful chemical."
So where's the hypocrisy?

Let's look at what Tony Clement and our government had to say about trans-fats - an absolutely proven to be harmful substance,
"We are giving industry two years to reduce trans fats to the lowest levels possible as recommended by the Trans Fat Task Force."
Our government needs to stop making policy on the basis of politics and instead make policy on the basis of evidence.

I guess the baby bottle industry lobby isn't as powerful as Big Food's.

[And before anyone gets themselves in knots regarding my personal stance on bisphenol-A (which I don't note above), you should know that my 15 month old now drinks from glass baby bottles. If there's no need to take a chance, why would I?

It's not that I'm suggesting the risk associated with BPA is or isn't a certainty, just that the evidence isn't in yet. The same cannot be said for trans-fats where the evidence is quite overwhelming, yet here's our government acting immediately on BPA and sitting on its trans-fat filled hands.]

Bookmark and Share

3 comments:

  1. Facinating, I am interested in seeing this BPA ban hit the market, will we notice it right away? Hmmmm

    ReplyDelete
  2. I read something on Canadian Freebies website.. saying something along the lines that you can return your bottles at Zellers and Wal Mart (if you bought them there). How are we supposed to know where we bought these bottles from years ago!?!

    ReplyDelete
  3. That generally true that new bans are introduced not because of the public sake but because it`s more convenient for the Government. As working as a Toronto life insurance broker I would say that our health care system needs to be radically reformed to make it more consumer-based. people also need to be provided better health edcation to not to believe all the nonsense one states.

    ReplyDelete