Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Are strollers contributing to childhood obesity?


Oy vey.

Last week I was filmed by CTV for a piece on a new study. It aired a few nights ago. The piece was exploring a new "study" that is being reported as illuminating a link between stroller time in 1-5 year olds and childhood obesity.

Never you mind that the study failed to include an objective measurement of activity in these kids to determine actual levels of physical activity, never you mind that we don't have data on stroller use in the years before the rise of childhood obesity, never you mind that the calories burned even in active play for 1-5 year olds aren't much to write home about, never you mind that studies on childhood obesity clearly suggest it's not a problem of inactivity, and that in fact obesity leads to inactivity, not inactivity to obesity - none of those things matter because hey, childhood obesity's always news.

I know, we'd all dearly love to blame childhood obesity on kids moving less, but at best that's a minor player, and stroller use in 1-5 year olds wouldn't likely make the top 100 chart of cause contributors.

While I'm not remotely surprised this hit the newswires, I'm actually surprised with the spin I've been reading. The study, despite its many methodological limitations, specifically states,

"When adjusted for age, birth weight, nutritional risk, maternal BMI, and maternal PA, there was no association between stroller use and zBMI (p=0.50) or z-WC (p=0.23)."
Meaning that the study didn't in fact suggest or infer stroller time as causal for obesity.

There are plenty of places to point fingers in regard to childhood obesity. What a shame to waste good airtime on something that anyone who actually took the time to read the study knows doesn't in fact matter.

[BTW - if you're looking for a reference, I don't believe it's actually been published yet, but if someone comes across it, I'm happy to put it up - Inactive Transport: Stroller Use and Physical Activity in Preschool Children: A Target Kids! Study *CS Birken, J Maguire, M Khovratovich, YY Wu, M Mamdani, BW McCrindle, PC Parkin Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Ontario]

Bookmark and Share

2 comments:

  1. Come on- it makes perfect sense: as long as you let your 2 year old kid WALK to McDonalds, you can let them have that extra large coke with their McNugget meal. In fact, why not just put it in their sippy cup for simplicity's sake? then it won't spill when they're walking home.

    Where's the camera? Come on, that must be a joke...

    Facepalm.

    Kirsten

    ReplyDelete
  2. What Kirsten said....

    Plus, I am pretty sure kids who spend a lot of time in strollers as opposed to car seats must be living in ACTIVE families, who walk rather than drive, I think the children are quite likely to imitate what they see when they are older. Plus, once they are too big for the stroller, they'll probably be walking beside mom or dad where ever they are being pushed right now.

    ReplyDelete